What are the stages of a criminal trial in India?

Legal Framework Governing the Criminal Trial Process

The criminal trial process in India is now governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which came into effect on 1 July 2024. Criminal offences are defined under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), and the rules of evidence are governed by the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA).

These three new criminal laws replaced the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

The BNSS lays down the stages of trial, types of offences, jurisdiction of courts, and procedures from investigation to judgment. It establishes whether a trial will be conducted summarily (for minor offences) or through a full trial (for serious offences).

Types of Trials Under the BNSS

Before examining the stages of trial, you must understand that not all criminal cases follow identical procedures. There are two broad categories:

Summary Trials

These are shorter trials conducted for minor offences punishable with imprisonment up to three years. They are faster, involve fewer formalities, and are decided by Magistrates.

Warrant Trials and Sessions Trials

These are conducted for serious offences, where the punishment may exceed three years. Warrant trials are held before Magistrates, while Sessions trials are conducted before Sessions Judges for grave offences punishable with life imprisonment or death.

The Complete Criminal Trial Process: Stages of Trial

Here is the step-by-step breakdown of the criminal trial process under the BNSS.

Stage 1: Filing of Charge Sheet or Complaint

Once police investigation is complete under Section 173 of the BNSS, a charge sheet (also called final report) is filed before the Magistrate. In cases where no investigation is required (private complaints), the complainant directly approaches the Magistrate under Section 200 of the BNSS.

The charge sheet lists the accused, evidence collected, and the offence committed under the BNS.

Stage 2: Cognizance of Offence

The Magistrate or Sessions Judge reviews the charge sheet or complaint and takes cognizance of the offence under Section 190 of the BNSS. This means the court formally acknowledges that a criminal case exists and decides whether it has enough merit to proceed.

If the offence is non-cognizable or bailable, the accused may be released on bail. If it is serious, the court may issue summons or a warrant for arrest.

Stage 3: Framing of Charges

After cognizance, the court examines the material presented and frames charges under Section 218 of the BNSS. This step clearly tells the accused:

• What offence they are charged with
• Which section of the BNS applies
• What evidence exists against them

The accused is asked whether they plead guilty or not guilty. If they plead guilty, the court may directly proceed to sentencing. If they plead not guilty, the trial moves forward.

Stage 4: Prosecution Evidence

This is the core of the criminal trial process. The prosecution presents its evidence to prove the charges. Evidence includes:

• Witness testimony
• Documentary evidence (medical reports, CCTV footage, emails, contracts)
• Physical evidence (weapons, seized material)

Each witness is examined in chief (questioned by the prosecution). Under Section 243 of the BNSS, the prosecution must present all evidence clearly and systematically.

Stage 5: Cross-Examination of Prosecution Witnesses

After the prosecution examines its witnesses, the defence lawyer cross-examines them under Section 137 of the BSA. Cross-examination tests the credibility of witnesses, exposes contradictions, and weakens the prosecution's case.

This is one of the most critical stages of trial because a strong cross-examination can result in acquittal.

Stage 6: Statement of the Accused (Section 315 BNSS)

Once the prosecution closes its case, the court examines the accused under Section 315 of the BNSS. The accused is asked to explain incriminating circumstances that emerged during the trial.

This statement is not made on oath, but it allows the accused to present their version of events. It can include:

• Denial of charges
• Explanation of conduct
• Alibi or alternative narrative

The accused is not compelled to answer, and silence cannot be used against them.

Stage 7: Defence Evidence

If the accused wishes, they may present defence evidence under Section 243 of the BNSS. This includes:

• Defence witnesses
• Documentary proof supporting innocence
• Expert testimony (forensic reports, medical opinions)

The prosecution can then cross-examine defence witnesses under the same principles applied earlier.

Stage 8: Final Arguments

Both sides present their final arguments under Section 248 of the BNSS. The prosecution summarizes the evidence, explains how it proves guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and cites relevant legal provisions under the BNS.

The defence argues why the evidence is insufficient, inconsistent, or unreliable. Final arguments are the last opportunity to convince the judge.

Stage 9: Judgment

The judge delivers the judgment under Section 354 of the BNSS. The judgment must state:

• Whether the accused is guilty or not guilty
• The reasoning behind the decision
• The points for determination
• Evidence considered

If the accused is acquitted, they are immediately released. If convicted, the case moves to sentencing.

Stage 10: Sentencing (if Convicted)

If found guilty, the court hears arguments on the quantum of sentence under Section 360 of the BNSS. Factors considered include:

• Severity of the offence
• Criminal history of the accused
• Age, gender, and mental condition
• Mitigating and aggravating circumstances

The court may impose imprisonment, fine, or both as per the BNS provisions applicable to the offence.

Stage 11: Appeals

If the convicted party believes the judgment is unjust, they can file an appeal in a higher court. The accused has the right to appeal to the Sessions Court (if convicted by a Magistrate) or the High Court (if convicted by a Sessions Judge). Appeals must be filed within the limitation period specified under the BNSS.

This step ensures checks and balances in the criminal trial process, providing an opportunity for judicial review.

Common Problems in the Criminal Trial Process

Understanding the criminal trial process is one thing. Facing it in reality is another. Here are common challenges individuals encounter:

Long Delays and Adjournments

Criminal trials in India are notorious for delays. Cases drag on for years due to witness non-appearance, lawyer unavailability, and court backlogs. A single adjournment can delay the trial by months.

Hostile or Absent Witnesses

Witnesses often turn hostile during cross-examination or fail to appear in court. This weakens the prosecution's case and may lead to acquittal even where guilt exists. The court may issue a bailable or non-bailable warrant to compel the witness to attend under Section 80 of the BNSS. Repeated non-appearance without valid reason may lead to contempt proceedings or fines.

Intimidation and Pressure Tactics

Accused persons or their associates may threaten witnesses, victims, or complainants. Fear prevents many from testifying truthfully, undermining the stages of trial.

Complex Procedures and Legal Jargon

The legal jargon and technicalities can be daunting for those unfamiliar with the law. Understanding when and how to apply the rules of criminal procedure can pose a significant challenge.

Insufficient Legal Representation

Many defendants may not secure adequate legal representation, impacting their chances of a fair trial and their ability to navigate the criminal trial process effectively.

Practical Guidance: What You Should Do

Whether you are a complainant, accused, or witness, here are practical steps to navigate the criminal trial process:

For Complainants

1. File the FIR immediately and obtain a copy
2. Preserve all evidence (medical records, CCTV footage, WhatsApp chats, documents)
3. Ensure witnesses are willing to testify and brief them on what to expect
4. Attend all court hearings and stay updated on case status
5. Appoint an experienced criminal lawyer who understands the stages of trial

For the Accused

1. Do not ignore summons or warrants; appear before the court
2. Apply for bail at the earliest stage possible
3. Collect alibi evidence, call records, and documentary proof supporting innocence
4. Do not communicate directly with witnesses or the complainant
5. Prepare thoroughly for the statement under Section 315 BNSS
6. Work closely with your legal counsel to prepare your case

For Witnesses

1. Testify truthfully without fear or favor
2. Inform the court if you feel threatened or pressured
3. Stick to facts and avoid speculation during cross-examination
4. Arrive on time and carry all required documents
5. Remain composed and attentive during hearings

Legal Advice: Things to Avoid

Mistakes made during the criminal trial process can have serious consequences. Avoid these common errors:

Tampering with Evidence

Destroying, fabricating, or altering evidence is an offence under Section 204 of the BNS (formerly Section 201 of the IPC). Courts treat this seriously and it strengthens the case against you. Failing to gather or present solid evidence can be detrimental to your case.

Skipping Court Hearings

Non-appearance without valid reason may result in warrant issuance or cancellation of bail. Always inform your lawyer in advance if you cannot attend. Be aware of the legal requirements and timelines involved.

Speaking to Witnesses Improperly

Any attempt to influence, threaten, or bribe witnesses is punishable under Section 214 of the BNS. This applies to both complainants and accused persons.

Disregarding Legal Procedures

Ignoring formal legal processes can jeopardize your case. Always comply with court orders and timelines. Never make agreements outside the court without legal consultation, as these may not hold in a trial setting.

Relying on Informal Advice

Criminal procedure is technical and changes frequently. Do not rely on hearsay or generic legal advice found online. Consult a qualified lawyer who understands the BNSS, BNS, and BSA framework.

When Should You Consult a Lawyer?

Professional legal consultation is necessary at every stage of trial. You must engage a lawyer if:

• You are accused of a criminal offence and need to apply for bail
• You are filing a private criminal complaint
• You are a witness and feel threatened or confused about testimony
• You are facing cross-examination or final arguments
• You wish to file an appeal after judgment
• You need clarity on the criminal trial process and your legal rights

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on the Criminal Trial Process

How long does a criminal trial take in India?

The duration depends on the complexity of the case, number of witnesses, and court workload. Summary trials may conclude in months, but serious offences tried in Sessions Courts can take years. Under the BNSS, courts are encouraged to expedite trials, but practical delays remain common.

Can I withdraw a criminal case once it starts?

It depends on the type of case. Private complaints filed under Section 200 of the BNSS may be withdrawn with court permission. But in cases where the police have filed a charge sheet, withdrawal is not automatic. The court must be satisfied that withdrawal serves justice.

What happens if a witness does not appear in court?

The court may issue a bailable or non-bailable warrant to compel the witness to attend under Section 80 of the BNSS. Repeated non-appearance without valid reason may lead to contempt proceedings or fines.

Can the accused remain silent during trial?

Yes. The accused has the right to remain silent and is not compelled to testify. However, under Section 315 of the BNSS, the accused must explain incriminating circumstances when asked by the court. Silence at that stage may strengthen the prosecution's case.

What is the difference between acquittal and discharge?

Discharge happens before the trial begins, at the stage of framing charges, if the court finds insufficient evidence. Acquittal happens after a full trial when the accused is found not guilty. Both result in release, but discharge is earlier in the criminal trial process.

Can I appeal if I am convicted?

Yes. The accused has the right to appeal to the Sessions Court (if convicted by a Magistrate) or the High Court (if convicted by a Sessions Judge). Appeals must be filed within the limitation period specified under the BNSS.

Is bail available during trial?

Yes. Bail can be applied for at various stages of trial depending on the offence. Bailable offences allow bail as a matter of right. Non-bailable offences require the court to consider factors like severity, evidence, and likelihood of tampering before granting bail.

What rights do defendants have during a criminal trial?

Defendants have several rights, including the right to legal representation, the right to remain silent, the right to a fair trial, the right to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, and the right to present defence evidence.

How is evidence presented in a criminal trial?

Evidence can be presented through witness testimonies, documents, and physical evidence aligned with the provisions of the BSA. Each piece of evidence must meet legal criteria for admissibility.

What happens if evidence is deemed inadmissible?

If evidence is ruled inadmissible, it cannot be considered in the trial, which can significantly weaken the case based on that evidence.

Key Takeaway

The criminal trial process in India is structured, rule-bound, and fair, but only if you understand the stages of trial and participate meaningfully. From framing of charges to judgment, each stage plays a role in ensuring justice. Whether you are a complainant seeking accountability or an accused defending your innocence, knowledge of criminal procedure under the BNSS is your greatest legal tool.

Understanding how trials work, what evidence matters, and when legal intervention is necessary can make the difference between conviction and acquittal, justice and injustice. This is not just about technicalities; it is about your freedom, reputation, and future.

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a qualified legal professional for specific guidance.

About LawCrust

LawCrust Legal Consulting, a subsidiary of LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd., is a top full-service legal firm in Mumbai, Delhi, Bangalore & across India, delivering strategic legal solutions for NRIs, HNIs, and businesses with a global perspective. Since 2016, we have successfully handled over 10,000 cases through a strong network of 70+ in-house lawyers and senior partnered advocates.

We represent clients across all levels of the judiciary, from Magistrate Courts and High Courts to the Supreme Court of India, handling complex matters including NRI divorce, cross-border property disputes, immigration, corporate governance, mergers & acquisitions (M&A), and structured finance.

LawCrust also pioneers innovative legal solutions such as Litigation Finance, the Legal Protect Plan, and specialized services for law firm startups and enterprise fundraising. With a commitment to confidentiality, senior expertise, and result-driven strategy, LawCrust stands as a trusted legal partner for high-impact and complex legal challenges.

For expert legal assistance, contact us:

Call Now: +91 8097842911

Email: inquiry@lawcrust.in