Affairs Leading to Real Relationships: Love, Law, and Life in India (2025 Update)
Love can transform lives, creating families, fostering personal growth, and providing profound meaning. But sometimes, love follows a complicated path: extramarital affairs. While Indian society often views infidelity with strong disapproval, some affairs leading to real relationships do evolve into genuine, lasting connections.
This article explores how an affair can transition into a committed relationship. We’ll examine the legal implications in India as of September 2025, from recent court judgments to proposed legislative changes. We’ll also provide practical guidance on navigating the emotional, social, and legal challenges involved, ensuring you have a comprehensive and clear understanding.
Can an Extramarital Affairs Leading to Real Relationship?
- Dynamics of Affairs Turning Into Real Relationships
When an affair becomes a committed relationship, several factors shape the journey:
- Emotional Connection vs Secrecy: Affairs often start due to unmet needs; openness can deepen intimacy but secrecy carries long-term costs.
- Shared Challenges: The guilt and secrecy can forge strong bonds, though emotionally complex.
- Personal Growth: Leaving a marriage forces reflection on values and desires, leading to growth and clarity.
Legal Updates in India (2025)
- Decriminalisation & Civil Impact: Since Joseph Shine vs Union of India (2018), adultery is not criminal but still a ground for divorce. Courts stress it isn’t a “license” for free affairs. Delhi HC allowed betrayed spouses to sue the lover for civil damages.
- Maintenance / Alimony: Chhattisgarh HC (2025) denied alimony to a wife proven in adultery. Madhya Pradesh HC ruled emotional involvement alone isn’t enough to deny maintenance.
- Evidence & Privacy: WhatsApp chats can be valid proof in divorce, even if obtained without consent, though privacy concerns remain.
- Proposed Re-criminalisation: A 2023 panel suggested reintroducing adultery as a gender-neutral offence under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. As of Sept 2025, this remains only a recommendation.
Navigating a Relationship Born from an Affair: Key Steps in India
If you are considering pursuing a “real relationship” after an affair, or are already in one, you need to navigate both legal and social challenges.
- Assess Your Situation Honestly
- How clean is the break from your previous marriage, emotionally, financially, and legally?
- Are there children involved? Consider custody, visitation, and alimony issues carefully.
- Consider Legal Separation or Divorce
Before entering into any new marital or public commitment, you must legally dissolve your previous marriage. Under the Hindu Marriage Act and other laws, adultery is a solid ground for divorce. You should seek a divorce legally to avoid future complications.
- Maintenance, Alimony, and Property Rights
If adultery is proven, the at-fault spouse may lose their entitlement to maintenance. The division of assets will depend on each partner’s contribution. The mere existence of an affair typically does not grant financial rights from the betrayed spouse, unless it is part of a divorce settlement.
Courts in India always prioritise the “best interest of the child.” An affair alone will not automatically disqualify you from getting custody. What matters is whether the child’s well-being has been compromised. Some judgments, however, do suggest that a proven negative impact of an affair on the child can affect custody decisions.
- Seek Professional Help
- Therapy or Counseling: This can help you deal with the emotional damage, rebuild trust, and set healthy boundaries in your new relationship.
- Legal Advice: Consulting with a family law specialist, like those at LawCrust, is crucial. They can provide guidance specific to your personal circumstances and state laws, as some personal laws differ by region and religion.
The Realities: Social, Emotional, and Cultural Context
Even if an affair becomes a “real relationship,” the journey is far from over.
- Social Stigma: Strong social disapproval still exists in many parts of India. The urban vs. rural divide, family structure, and community norms can all play a significant role.
- Emotional Baggage: Guilt, betrayal, and new expectations can weigh heavily. Healing takes time for everyone involved.
- Resistance and Acceptance: Your new partner may face resistance from the ex-spouse, families, and communities. Building a new life with acceptance takes patience and resilience.
Expert Tips for Healing and Building a Successful Relationship
- Be Transparent: Once you decide to move forward, be honest with all parties, where possible, about what happened and what you hope to build.
- Embrace Counseling: Individual and couples therapy can help you address regrets and navigate trust issues.
- Get Financial and Legal Clarity: Make sure all legal issues divorce deeds, property rights, and maintenance obligations are resolved to avoid future surprises.
- Slow Down: Rebuilding a life with children and family takes time. Learn from past mistakes and set realistic expectations for your new relationship.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is adultery a criminal offense in India now?
No. It is no longer a criminal offense since the Supreme Court’s 2018 judgment. However, it continues to have serious civil and matrimonial consequences.
Can the betrayed spouse sue the “other person”?
Yes. A betrayed spouse can sue the paramour for civil damages, such as compensation for emotional injury or loss of companionship.
Can a spouse be denied maintenance due to adultery?
Yes. If a spouse is proven to have committed adultery, courts have the right to deny them maintenance. However, proof of a physical relationship is generally required, as a mere emotional affair may not be enough.
What counts as evidence in such cases?
Digital messages, such as WhatsApp chats, are being admitted as evidence in some courts. Witness testimony or confessions can also be used. However, remember that courts weigh privacy rights carefully, and improperly collected evidence can be challenged.
Is there a move to re-criminalize adultery?
A Parliamentary panel has recommended making adultery a gender-neutral criminal offense again. However, as of September 2025, no law has been passed to make this change.
Conclusion
Affairs leading to real relationships are possible, but transforming an affair into a healthy, sustainable connection involves confronting emotional damage, navigating legal complexities, and overcoming social stigma. In India, while adultery is no longer a crime, its civil consequences remain significant, impacting divorce, maintenance, compensation, and child custody.
If you are in or are considering such a relationship, seeking legal counsel from experts, like those at Tigde Law Firm, and emotional support is wise. With clarity, integrity, and respect, healing and honesty can pave the way for a real connection.
About LawCrust Legal Consultation.
LawCrust Legal Consulting, a subsidiary of LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd., is a trusted legal partner for NRIs and Indians across the globe. Backed by a team of over 70 expert lawyers and more than 25 empanelled law firms, we offer a wide range of Premium Legal Services both in India and internationally. Our expertise spans across legal finance, litigation management, matrimonial disputes, property matters, estate planning, heirship certificates, RERA, and builder-related legal issues.
In addition to personal legal matters, LawCrust also provides expert support in complex corporate areas such as foreign direct investment (FDI), foreign institutional investment (FII), mergers & acquisitions, and fundraising. We also assist clients with OCI and immigration matters, startup solutions, and hybrid consulting solutions. Consistently ranked among the top legal consulting firms in India, LawCrust proudly delivers customised legal solutions across the UK, USA, Canada, Europe, Australia, APAC, and EMEA, offering culturally informed and cross-border expertise to meet the unique needs of the global Indian community.