Resolving Housing Dispute Over Common Terraces or Rooftops in India
If you are a resident in a cooperative housing society in India and are facing a housing dispute over access to common terraces or rooftops, it is essential to understand your legal rights and the correct procedures to follow. While a direct, friendly approach is often the best first step, when that fails, Indian law provides clear, structured pathways for resolution. The most effective way to handle these issues is to use the established legal framework, relying on the society’s bye-laws and relevant state cooperative laws, with the guidance of a professional housing lawyer.
The legal process for a housing dispute over a terrace or rooftop must be handled with care. These spaces are typically considered common areas for all members, and any attempt by an individual to claim exclusive access can be challenged. This guide outlines the legal steps, drawing on real-world scenarios and recent legal developments in India, particularly in states like Maharashtra, to empower you with the knowledge needed to achieve a fair outcome.
Understanding the Legal Status of Terraces and Rooftops
Common vs. Exclusive Rights
In a cooperative housing society, terraces and rooftops are generally designated as common areas. This means they are for the use and enjoyment of all society members, subject to the rules laid down in the society’s bye-laws.
- Common Areas: Unless a sale deed or an apartment ownership agreement explicitly states otherwise, these spaces are shared. No single member can claim exclusive ownership or restrict access for others.
- Exclusive Use Rights: In rare cases, a society may grant a member, such as a penthouse owner, exclusive rights to a terrace. The deed of conveyance and the society’s bye-laws must clearly document this grant. Without such documentation, a member’s claim to exclusive use lacks legal validity, and other members can challenge it as a housing dispute.
The Legal Framework
The legal handling of a housing dispute over common areas is governed by several key provisions:
- Society Bye-laws: These are the most important documents for a society. They outline the rules for using common spaces, maintenance responsibilities, and the internal dispute resolution process. Any dispute should begin with a review of these bye-laws.
- Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960: For societies in Maharashtra, this Act is the primary legal authority. It contains provisions that govern the management of common properties and provide mechanisms for members to seek redressal. The Act and its recent amendments, such as the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies (Amendment) Bill, 2025, offer streamlined processes for conflict resolution.
- Judicial Precedents: Indian courts, including the Supreme Court and the Bombay High Court, have repeatedly ruled that terraces are common property. Landmark judgments, such as the 2017 case of Dr. Ramesh Chunilal Hansoti vs. Others, have affirmed the society’s right to reclaim encroached terraces.
A Step-by-Step Guide to Resolving Housing Disputes Over Common Terraces or Rooftops
To ensure a housing dispute is handled legally and effectively, follow this structured approach:
1. Internal Resolution
Start by attempting to resolve the issue within the society. This is often the fastest and most cost-effective method, helping maintain harmony without legal escalation.
2. Submit a Formal Complaint
The aggrieved member(s) should write a formal complaint to the society’s Managing Committee, clearly detailing the issue and referencing the relevant bye-laws. This creates an official, documented record.
3. Managing Committee Intervention
The Managing Committee should:
- Issue a formal notice to the member causing the dispute.
- Convene a special meeting to discuss potential resolutions.
This step ensures that the society takes proactive responsibility while maintaining neutrality.
4. Raise the Issue at a General Body Meeting
If the dispute persists, bring it to a General Body Meeting (GBM). Resolutions passed by a majority of members carry legal weight and reflect the collective decision of the society.
5. Mediation and Arbitration
- Utilise internal mediation mechanisms outlined in the society’s bye-laws.
- For more contentious disputes, consider arbitration under the Cooperative Societies Act.
- Engaging a cooperative society lawyer as a mediator can prevent escalation and achieve a binding resolution efficiently.
6. Approach the Registrar of Cooperative Societies
If internal measures fail, escalate the matter legally:
- Members can file a formal complaint with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies.
- The Registrar can investigate and issue directives to enforce bye-laws.
- Local expertise from lawyers for society matters in Mumbai ensures the process is navigated correctly.
7. Filing a Civil Suit
For persistent or complex disputes:
- File a civil suit in a competent court, such as a Cooperative Court.
- Courts can issue permanent injunctions to prevent illegal use of common areas.
- Fines or penalties can also be imposed to enforce compliance.
8. Involve Municipal Authorities
For illegal structures or encroachments on terraces or rooftops:
- File a complaint with the municipal corporation, such as the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC).
- The BMC can issue notices and order demolition of illegal constructions, as highlighted in a 2022 Bombay High Court directive.
The Role of Expert Legal Assistance
Engaging a professional legal expert is crucial for successfully resolving a housing dispute. A housing lawyer or a lawyer for cooperative society matters provides invaluable assistance by:
- Providing Housing Legal Advice: They can offer clarity on your rights and obligations under the law, ensuring you take the correct steps.
- Drafting Legal Documents: A lawyer can draft legal notices, formal complaints, and petitions to the Registrar or the court, ensuring all documents are legally sound.
- Representation: A housing dispute lawyer can represent you or the society in mediation, arbitration, and court proceedings, presenting your case effectively.
- Local Expertise: A cooperative housing society lawyer in Mumbai, for instance, will have specific knowledge of local laws, common precedents, and the procedures of the Registrar’s office, which can significantly expedite the resolution process.
Case Study: A Real-World Scenario
Consider a family on the top floor of a Mumbai apartment building who installed a large, private garden on the common rooftop, restricting access for other residents. The society’s managing committee, guided by a society lawyer, first issued a formal notice citing the bye-laws. When the family refused to comply, the society filed a complaint with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. The Registrar, after a hearing, ordered the family to remove the garden and restore the terrace to its common state, saving the society from a protracted court battle. This highlights the importance of a clear, legally backed approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What rights do NRIs and OCIs have in resolving terrace access disputes in Indian housing societies?
NRIs and OCIs have the same legal rights as resident members. They can appoint a power of attorney holder to file complaints with the Registrar or Cooperative Court. Recent legal amendments, such as the 2025 digital governance rules, also allow for electronic filings and virtual hearings, making it easier for non-residents to participate in legal services housing from abroad.
2. Can a member use a terrace exclusively if the society disagrees?
No. The society only legally grants exclusive use if the bye-laws or a prior agreement explicitly allow it. Otherwise, the member encroaches on common property, and other members can challenge it as a valid housing dispute.”
3. How can an NRI or OCI file a housing dispute complaint from abroad?
NRIs and OCIs can submit complaints to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies through a designated representative with a power of attorney. They can also utilise online portals and digital communication, which the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies (Amendment) Bill, 2025, has further streamlined. Engaging a specialised housing lawyer near me who handles cross-border cases is highly recommended.
4. What if an NRI faces an encroachment on a terrace in their Mumbai property?
An NRI should first notify the Managing Committee in writing. If no action is taken, they can escalate the matter to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies or the BMC. Recent court directives in Mumbai have mandated swift action against such blockages, and a lawyer for housing issues can help facilitate these filings.
5. What legal updates affect NRI and OCI involvement in housing disputes?
The recent Maharashtra Co-operative Societies (Amendment) Bill, 2025, introduces provisions for virtual general body meetings and streamlined online dispute resolution, which significantly enhances the ability of NRIs and OCIs to participate in and resolve legal services housing matters without having to travel to India.
Outlook
As urbanisation continues, especially in cities like Mumbai, disputes over common areas like terraces are likely to become more common. However, with evolving laws and a growing emphasis on transparency and fair governance, societies now have better tools to handle these conflicts. Proactive societies that update their bye-laws and seek expert legal advice for housing issues can prevent minor disagreements from escalating into costly legal battles, ensuring community harmony and protecting the rights of all members.
About LawCrust Legal Consultation.
LawCrust Legal Consulting, a subsidiary of LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd., is a trusted legal partner for NRIs and Indians across the globe. Backed by a team of over 70 expert lawyers and more than 25 empanelled law firms, we offer a wide range of Premium Legal Services both in India and internationally. Our expertise spans across legal finance, litigation management, matrimonial disputes, property matters, estate planning, heirship certificates, RERA, and builder-related legal issues.
In addition to personal legal matters, LawCrust also provides expert support in complex corporate areas such as foreign direct investment (FDI), foreign institutional investment (FII), mergers & acquisitions, and fundraising. We also assist clients with OCI and immigration matters, startup solutions, and hybrid consulting solutions. Consistently ranked among the top legal consulting firms in India, LawCrust proudly delivers customised legal solutions across the UK, USA, Canada, Europe, Australia, APAC, and EMEA, offering culturally informed and cross-border expertise to meet the unique needs of the global Indian community.