Understanding Contingency Contracts and Contingent Contract in India
Imagine hiring someone and paying them only when they deliver. That idea sits at the heart of Contingent Contract. In India, these kinds of deals are common in business, real estate, startups, and even insurance. They help people share risk and stay flexible. This guide explains what these contracts mean under Indian law, how to draft them clearly, what risks to watch for, and practical tips for resolving disputes. I’ll also explain how new criminal law changes like the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita can overlap with contract problems.
What is a Contingent Contract?
A Contingent Contract is an agreement where someone must do something only if a future event happens or doesn’t happen. The contract depends on that unknown event. So the deal becomes enforceable only when the condition happens. If the condition becomes impossible, usually the contract ends.
The Legal Base: Indian Contract Act, 1872
In India, the rules for these contracts come from the Indian Contract Act, 1872, especially Sections 31 to 36. Here’s the basic idea in simple words:
- Section 31 defines a contingent contract as an agreement to act or not act based on some future event that is not part of the main promise.
- Section 32 says the contract only becomes enforceable when the event occurs; if the event becomes impossible, the contract is void.
- Sections 33–36 explain other situations like contracts based on non-happening of an event, events within a fixed time, impossible acts, and duties when the promisor must bring about the event.
Always read these sections closely when you plan or argue a contract in court.
How the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) Connects
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita updates criminal law, not contract law. But it matters if a contract dispute involves crimes like fraud, cheating, or criminal breach of trust. If someone lies to make a contingency happen, BNS rules will apply to any criminal case, while the civil contract dispute stays under the Contract Act. So you may need both civil and criminal strategies.
Where Contingency Contracts Show Up in Real Life
These agreements are everywhere. Common examples include:
- Real estate deals where payment depends on a home loan or clear title.
- Mergers & acquisitions where part of the price depends on future revenue targets (earn-outs).
- Construction projects offering bonuses for early completion or staying under budget.
- Performance-based bonuses for employees or consultants tied to measurable goals.
- Insurance policies that pay out only if an accident or loss happens.
Limits on Lawyers and “No Win, No Fee” Arrangements
People sometimes think lawyers can take cases on a percentage basis you pay only if you win. In India, this is normally not allowed for litigation. The Bar Council of India rules stop advocates from charging fees based on the outcome or sharing proceeds of a case. This keeps the legal profession ethical and avoids conflicts of interest.
That said, contingency-style payments can still work outside court. For example, a consultant can get paid more if a project succeeds, or an advisor can receive part of the fee when a deal closes. The key is that litigation contingency fees remain restricted.
What Makes a Contingent Contract Valid?
To be enforceable in India, a contingent contract must include standard contract basics plus a clear contingency:
- Clear offer and acceptance
- Lawful consideration (something of value exchanged)
- Competent parties (of legal age and sound mind)
- Free consent (no fraud, coercion, or mistake)
- A lawful object (not against public policy)
- An uncertain future event that is collateral to the contract
Drafting Checklist: Make It Enforceable
Courts will refuse to enforce fuzzy terms. Use this checklist to write better contingency clauses:
- Define the contingency precisely: Use measurable terms dates, amounts, names of authorities.
- State whether it’s a condition precedent or subsequent: Clarify whether performance waits for the event or continues unless the event happens.
- Set time limits: Don’t leave it open-ended set deadlines or time windows.
- Specify who proves the event: Say which party must provide proof and what documents count.
- Decide remedies: Explain what happens if the event doesn’t happen refunds, termination, liquidated damages, renegotiation.
- Handle impossibility and force majeure: Include backup plans when outside events block the contingency.
- Pick dispute resolution: Choose arbitration or courts and the governing law usually Indian law.
- Stamp and register correctly: Follow state stamp acts and registration rules if required.
Practical Draft Examples
Here are two simple, clear model clauses you can adapt:
- Condition precedent (real estate): This agreement becomes effective only if the Municipal Corporation of Mumbai grants change-of-use approval for Plot A by 31 March 2026. The buyer will provide a certified copy of the approval; the seller may verify.
- Earn-out (M&A): Seller will receive an extra INR 2,00,00,000 if the company’s audited net revenue for FY 2025–26 equals or exceeds INR 25 crore, certified by the statutory auditors.
Common Legal Issues and Case Law
Court decisions show judges want clear proof the contingency happened. A few examples:
- Nandkishore Lalbhai v. New Era Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (Supreme Court, 2015) The Court refused to enforce a land sale contingent on statutory approvals that never arrived.
- Urmila Devi Jain & Ors. v. Ashok Kumar & Ors. (Patna High Court, 2024) The court stressed that a contingent contract is not enforceable until the condition is met.
- Bar Council of India vs. A.K. Balaji (2018) The Supreme Court’s stance reinforced limits on foreign law firms and confirmed ethical rules around lawyer fees, which affects contingency-style legal payment models.
These rulings show courts check the clarity and proof behind any claimed contingency before enforcing obligations.
How to Handle Disputes Step by Step
If a disagreement pops up, follow these practical steps:
- Preserve evidence: Save emails, approvals, receipts, and certified documents.
- Check contract terms: Find whether the contingency is a condition precedent or something else.
- Try negotiation or mediation: Many disputes settle faster this way.
- Use arbitration if agreed: Arbitration can be quicker and private.
- File suit if needed: If settlement fails and the contingency occurred, you can sue for specific performance or damages.
- Consider criminal angles: If you suspect fraud or forgery, file a criminal complaint BNS rules will govern criminal procedures.
Risks and How to Avoid Them
- Vague wording fix it by being precise.
- Open timelines set clear deadlines.
- Third-party dependency allocate risk when approvals depend on others or the government.
- Poor proof rules state exactly what documents count as proof.
- Failure to stamp or register follow state law on stamps and registration to avoid challenges.
Practical Tips for Different People
- Real estate buyers: Ask for escrow, refund clauses, and a clear silent period for approvals.
- Startups & founders: Tie vesting and earn-outs to measurable KPIs and independent auditor checks.
- Investors: Define material adverse event (MAE) triggers and audit rights before closing.
- Lenders: Put security and trigger events into loan agreements and verify conditions independently.
- Lawyers: Draft measurable, time-bound clauses and include fallback remedies.
FAQs
- What are contingent contracts in India?
Ans: Agreements whose performance depends on a future uncertain event, governed by Sections 31–36 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
- When does a contingent contract become enforceable?
Ans: When the specified event happens. If it becomes impossible, the contract usually becomes void.
- How to draft a clear contingency clause?
Ans: Use specific events, name authorities, fix deadlines, state proof rules, and set remedies.
- Can they be partially performed?
Ans: Generally no, unless the contract explicitly allows partial performance.
- Do these contracts need stamping or registration?
Ans: Often yes check your state’s stamp act and the Registration Act for property deals.
- How does BNS affect these contracts?
Ans: BNS affects criminal issues that arise from contract disputes, but it doesn’t change contract law itself.
- What if the other party refuses to honor the contingency?
Ans: Preserve evidence, issue a legal notice, try mediation, then arbitrate or sue if needed.
Outlook: What to Expect
Contingency Contracts will stay important for managing risk in real estate, M&A, startups, and lending. Courts will keep demanding clear proof and measurable conditions before enforcing such agreements. Because criminal law reform under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita changes how fraud and related crimes are handled, parties must align civil and criminal strategies when wrongdoing is suspected. Draft carefully, collect evidence, and get legal advice early.
About LawCrust Legal Consulting
LawCrust Legal Consulting, a part of LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd., stands as one of India’s trusted names in legal and consulting services. Our team works across a wide range of areas to support both businesses and individuals.
We offer services such as litigation finance, legal protection, litigation management, startup support, fundraising guidance, hybrid consulting, mergers and acquisitions, insolvency & bankruptcy, and debt restructuring.
We also help people with matrimonial matters, property disputes, criminal cases, civil issues, immigration concerns, NRI legal support, society matters, and estate planning. Along with this, we provide ALSP and LPO services to clients in India and overseas.
Our network includes more than fifty offices across India and a team of over seventy specialised lawyers. This helps us offer steady and reliable support for many legal needs.
You can also use our legal app to connect with lawyers quickly. It is one of the most helpful legal apps available, so feel free to download it.
LawCrust Groups also includes several companies such as LawCrust Realty, LawCrust Ventures, LawCrust Hybrid Consulting, Gensact, LawCrust Foundation, and LawCrust Consumer Products.
Need Legal Help? Contact Us
You can reach us anytime for expert legal support.